1041 Buttonwood Dr: A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key

Date of Publishing: December 17, 2025

Set against the endless horizon of open water in the Lower Florida Keys, 1041 Buttonwood Dr emerges as one of the most ambitious and architecturally resilient private residences currently offered within Summerland Key real estate. Priced at $11 million, this newly completed waterfront estate represents a rare convergence of modern design, fortress-level construction, and elevated island living, an offering that redefines what a home in Summerland Key for sale can be in today’s luxury market.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 1

Completed in 2025 and spanning nearly 4,900 square feet, the single-family residence stands on approximately 0.30 acres within the sought-after Sugarloaf Shores enclave. From the outset, the property signals its intent: this is not a traditional Florida retreat, but a purpose-built modern stronghold designed for discerning ultra-high-net-worth buyers who demand both architectural clarity and absolute peace of mind.

A Concrete Vision Built for Permanence

Unlike many coastal homes that rely on lighter construction methods, 1041 Buttonwood Dr was engineered entirely of reinforced concrete, adhering to some of the most stringent hurricane-resistant building standards in the region. According to Lisa Swanson of The Agency Florida Keys, the home’s listing agent, this approach was deliberate. “The vision behind this estate was to create something enduring,” Swanson told Luxury Houses Magazine. “This is a concrete structure designed to withstand extreme coastal conditions while still delivering a refined, modern aesthetic that feels effortless rather than defensive.”

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 9

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 8

That balance between strength and elegance defines the home’s architectural language. Clean horizontal lines, expansive glazing, and minimalist detailing allow the structure to feel sculptural without overpowering its natural surroundings. Floor-to-ceiling impact-resistant glass wraps the primary living areas, dissolving the boundary between interior space and open water.

SEE MORE: $17.9 Million Historic Waterfront Estate A Rare Icon of Timeless Luxury in West Palm Beach

Interior Architecture: Light, Scale, and Precision

Upon entering the main living level, visitors are immediately greeted by a dramatic 19-foot double-volume living space, where glass walls frame sweeping water views in every direction. Rather than overwhelming the space with ornamentation, the interior palette remains restrained and intentional. Porcelain floors, sleek interior glass railings, and refined finishes establish a calm, contemporary atmosphere that places emphasis on proportion and light.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 6

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 7

The kitchen anchors the open plan with a sense of quiet authority. Brazilian quartzite countertops, integrated Monogram appliances, and a bespoke bar arrangement speak to the home’s suitability for both intimate gatherings and large-scale entertaining. A sculptural stone wine display serves as a visual centerpiece, reinforcing the estate’s lifestyle-driven design philosophy rather than a purely functional one.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 3

Four private primary suites are positioned to maximize water exposure, each offering direct access to covered terraces. These suites are intentionally designed as self-contained retreats, ensuring privacy while maintaining a visual connection to the surrounding seascape. The remaining bedroom accommodations are equally generous, allowing the residence to comfortably host family, guests, or extended stays.

SEE MORE: A $25.8 Million Contemporary Masterpiece Redefining Luxury Living Inside Jupiter’s Elite Bear’s Club

Rooftop Living and Elevated Outdoor Experiences

What truly sets 1041 Buttonwood Dr apart within the Summerland Key home for sale landscape is its expansive flat rooftop deck. Spanning the entire footprint of the main residence, this elevated platform delivers uninterrupted 360-degree views across the Atlantic and Gulf waters, a feature rarely executed at this scale in the Lower Keys.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 11

“It’s rare to see a rooftop deck of this magnitude executed so cleanly,” Swanson noted in a follow-up conversation with Luxury Houses. “The views here aren’t just scenic; they’re immersive. Sunrise, sunset, storm systems rolling in, you experience the Keys from a completely different perspective.”

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 10

At ground level, outdoor living continues with a resort-style pool and spa, framed by covered entertaining spaces and thoughtful landscape lighting. A dedicated cabana bath connects directly to the pool area, reinforcing the home’s seamless indoor-outdoor flow. For boating enthusiasts, the inclusion of a 230-foot private dock elevates the property into a true waterfront compound rather than a simple coastal residence.

SEE MORE: A $19.9 Million Stunning Tropical Contemporary Estate Steps From the Beach in Prestigious Naples

Function Meets Flexibility

Beyond aesthetics, the estate demonstrates a high level of functional intelligence. An above-flood concrete garage with soaring ceilings provides secure parking, loft storage, and dual cistern systems, an important consideration in Summerland Key real estate, where self-sufficiency and preparedness are highly valued.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 2

Above the garage, a separate set of luxury living quarters includes a kitchenette, washer and dryer, full bathroom, and a flexible room that can easily serve as a guest suite, private office, or fitness studio. This configuration adds a layer of versatility that appeals to modern buyers seeking adaptable spaces without compromising privacy.

Market History and Value Trajectory

Public records reviewed by Luxury Houses Magazine reveal a compelling transformation story behind 1041 Buttonwood Dr. The property last traded for approximately $1.5 million in 2022, followed by a subsequent sale in early 2024 at $3.1 million. The current $11 million listing reflects not market inflation alone, but a complete architectural reinvention driven by new construction and elevated design ambition.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 4

According to Swanson, the pricing aligns with a growing segment of buyers entering the Lower Florida Keys market. “We’re seeing buyers who are no longer comparing Summerland Key to nearby islands,” she explained. “They’re comparing it to global waterfront destinations. This home competes on that level.”

Summerland Key: A Lifestyle Defined by Privacy and Access

Located approximately 20 miles east of Key West, Summerland Key offers a quieter alternative to its more tourist-driven neighbors while maintaining easy access via the Overseas Highway. Residents enjoy proximity to marinas, local dining institutions, and everyday services without sacrificing the sense of seclusion that defines the island’s appeal.

1041 Buttonwood Dr A Monument of Modern Waterfront Luxury in Summerland Key 5

Within the broader context of Summerland Key real estate, properties like 1041 Buttonwood Dr represent a shift toward architecturally significant, design-forward estates that prioritize longevity and lifestyle equally. Fishing, boating, and water sports remain central to daily life, while the community’s low-density character continues to attract privacy-minded homeowners.

An Editorial Perspective

Luxury Houses attempted to contact the current owner of 1041 Buttonwood Dr to gain further insight into the personal vision behind the residence but did not receive a response prior to publication. That discretion, however, feels entirely consistent with the property itself, measured, intentional, and designed for those who value substance over spectacle.

What stands out most is not a single feature, but the cohesion of the entire estate. In a market saturated with luxury claims, 1041 Buttonwood Dr delivers a rare sense of architectural honesty, structural confidence, and lifestyle clarity.

Conclusion

For buyers seeking a home in Summerland Key for sale that transcends traditional coastal design, 1041 Buttonwood Dr offers a compelling proposition. It is at once a modern sanctuary, a resilient waterfront fortress, and a refined expression of contemporary island living. Within the evolving landscape of Summerland Key real estate, this estate stands as a benchmark, quietly powerful, meticulously executed, and unmistakably rare. To know more this property, view on Zillow listing.

For inquiries or to schedule a private showing, please contact:

Lisa Swanson
305-924-3777
The Agency Florida Keys

* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*

An $11 Million Extraordinary Waterfront Fortress Elevating Modern Luxury in Summerland Key