Live the Ultimate Waterfront Lifestyle in This $8.9 Million Gulf-Access Estate on Marco Island
A Jewel on Robert’s Bay
Situated on the sparkling waters of Robert’s Bay, 1611 Collingswood Ct is an extraordinary home in Marco Island for sale that blends refined architectural craftsmanship with a rare southern exposure. Priced at $8.9 million, this Marco Island real estate masterpiece offers 7,061 square feet of meticulously designed living space on a 0.43-acre lot, with direct Gulf access that turns every boating enthusiast’s dream into reality. Built in 2014, the residence embraces modern coastal elegance, combining the strength of high-end structural engineering with the grace of thoughtful interior design.
From the moment you arrive beneath the grand porte cochere, the sense of scale and opulence becomes evident. Stepping into the soaring three-story foyer, you are met with a panoramic view through 10-foot sliding glass doors that frame the open living area and Robert’s Bay beyond. The great room, crowned with an 18-foot ceiling, centers around a contemporary gas fireplace, seamlessly flowing into a chef’s kitchen complete with premium appliances, custom cabinetry, and a generous island for casual gatherings.
Interior Spaces Designed for Lifestyle
The ground floor hosts a master suite that redefines privacy and indulgence, featuring dual walk-in closets, separate water closets, and even a private laundry area. This level also accommodates a professional office space and an oversized flex room that can be transformed into a media lounge, secondary master suite, or private guest quarters. For automotive aficionados, the air-conditioned four-car garage boasts ceilings high enough to accommodate vehicle lifts, creating storage for multiple luxury cars.
Ascending via the grand staircase or elevator, the second floor unfolds with three guest bedrooms, each with ensuite baths, alongside a wet bar, storage room, and a versatile gym or relaxation lounge. From here, the second-level lanai invites you to unwind, while a spiral staircase leads to the third-floor viewing deck – perfect for sunsets over the bay. The home offers a total of seven baths – five full and two half – ensuring every guest enjoys comfort and privacy.
Outdoor Living and Amenities
Beyond its interiors, 1611 Collingswood Ct embraces Florida’s alfresco lifestyle with a lanai that spans the back of the home, integrating two distinct living areas, an outdoor kitchen, and a built-in barbecue. The infinity-edge pool appears to merge with the bay, while the adjacent hot tub offers year-round relaxation. The entire lanai is protected by electric hurricane and security shutters, complementing the property’s impact-rated windows and metal roof for uncompromising safety. A private dock with no-bridge access allows seamless navigation to the Gulf, making it a rare asset even among premier Marco Island home for sale.
Listing agent Katherine Joyce of Premiere Plus Realty Company told Luxury Houses Magazine, “The buyers will appreciate the meticulous care in every design detail – from structural integrity to the soft finishes. This home represents the pinnacle of Gulf-front living.” Her sentiment echoes throughout the property, where function and beauty exist in perfect balance.
A Rich Sales History
The story of 1611 Collingswood Ct is as compelling as its architecture. Sold in 1997 for $450,000, the property changed hands in 1999, 2003, and 2012 before its transformation into the current residence. Following its 2014 completion, it entered the luxury market in July 2024 at $10.9 million. Strategic price adjustments in early 2025 positioned it competitively at $8.9 million by July 24, 2025, drawing interest from high-net-worth buyers seeking both location and lifestyle. Public records identify the current owners as W. Scott and Brenda S. Rhinehart, though they have declined to comment. As Luxury Houses notes, “We reached out to the homeowners for additional insights but received no response, a reminder that some estates prefer to let their grandeur speak for itself.”
Community, Connectivity, and Lifestyle
The estate’s location in Marco Beach Unit 9 places it at the heart of Marco Island’s vibrant yet tranquil lifestyle. The island boasts six miles of white sand beaches, more than 100 miles of navigable waterways, and easy access to both Naples and the Gulf of Mexico. Residents enjoy proximity to fine dining restaurants, boutique shopping, cultural events, and championship golf courses. Nearby marinas cater to yachting and sport fishing, while the island’s family-friendly reputation is supported by top-rated schools such as Tommie Barfield Elementary.
Luxury real estate specialist Joyce added, “Marco Island offers a lifestyle that’s as much about the water as it is about the community. Homes like 1611 Collingswood Ct are rare because they offer both privacy and connection to everything this island has to offer.”
Architectural Integrity and Investment Value
From its block-and-stucco construction to its hurricane-rated windows and whole-house generator, 1611 Collingswood Ct is built to endure. The open floor plan, enhanced by natural light and strategic sightlines, maximizes bay views from nearly every room. Custom millwork, designer tile, and vaulted ceilings enhance its sense of scale, while modern systems – multi-zone climate control, an elevator, and integrated security – deliver comfort and peace of mind.
A Naples-based luxury market analyst shared with Luxury Houses Magazine, “The current pricing positions this home attractively against other Marco Island waterfront estates. Given its construction quality and location, it’s not just a lifestyle purchase – it’s a smart long-term asset.”
SEE MORE: WaterColor’s Most Refined $11.2 Million Estate Blends Coastal Luxury with Smart Living
The Final Word
Priced at $8.9 million, 1611 Collingswood Ct is more than a home – it’s a statement of coastal elegance and enduring value. With direct Gulf access, panoramic water views, and a design that blends durability with beauty, it stands among the finest Marco Island real estate offerings of 2025. For buyers seeking a sanctuary that honors both privacy and connection, this estate delivers a rare combination.
In the words of Joyce, “This is a property where every sunrise feels like a celebration, and every sunset feels like a private showing.” And for those ready to step into this world of refined coastal living, 1611 Collingswood Ct awaits.
For more information, view on Zillow listing.
For inquiries or to schedule a private showing, please contact:
Katherine Joyce
845-323-9005
Premiere Plus Realty Company
* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*
More Homes in Florida here:
- Live the Ultimate Waterfront Lifestyle in This $8.9 Million Gulf-Access Estate on Marco Island
- Exceptional $19.8 Million Modern Waterfront Retreat in Fort Lauderdale with Iconic Design and Smart Features
- Timeless $6.5 Million Winter Park Estate Offers Grand Interiors, Lush Gardens, and Expansion Potential
- WaterColor’s Most Refined $11.2 Million Estate Blends Coastal Luxury with Smart Living
