Classic Grandeur Meets the Water: A $8.5M Manor Overlooking Oyster Bay Harbor
Perched above the shoreline with commanding views across Oyster Bay Harbor, 200# Centre Island Road represents one of the most distinguished waterfront offerings currently available on Long Island. Priced at $8.5 million, the 6-bedroom, 7.5-bath estate spans 7,047 square feet and occupies 1.71 acres with approximately 245 feet of direct water frontage, placing it firmly among the most desirable addresses in Centre Island Real Estate.
Built in 2009, the residence was envisioned as a modern interpretation of a classic Colonial manor, combining traditional architectural symmetry with contemporary infrastructure and resort-level amenities. “The home was designed to feel timeless rather than trendy,” the listing agent told Luxury Houses Magazine. “From the proportions to the materials, everything was selected to endure both stylistically and structurally.”
Architecture Designed Around Light and Water
A dramatic sense of arrival defines 200# Centre Island Road, beginning with grand mahogany entry doors that open to a formal foyer accented by fielded wainscot paneling. Beyond, the great room unfolds beneath a soaring two-story ceiling, anchored by a floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace and clerestory windows that flood the interior with natural light. Three sets of French doors frame uninterrupted harbor views, creating a seamless connection between the interior and the waterfront setting.
The formal dining room is tailored for elegant entertaining, while the chef’s kitchen serves as the heart of the home. Custom cabinetry, professional-grade appliances, dual walk-in pantries, and an expansive marble center island are complemented by an octagonal breakfast area overlooking the shoreline. According to the agent, “This is a house where every primary room has a visual relationship with the water, which is increasingly rare in today’s New York Real Estate market.”
SEE MORE: An Extraordinary Waterfront Villa in Lloyd Harbor’s Exclusive Enclave, Asking $10.5 Million
A Private Primary Suite and Entertaining Lower Level
The main-level primary suite is positioned as a true retreat, offering panoramic harbor views, two walk-in closets with center islands, and a spa-quality marble bathroom featuring a soaking tub and a dual shower. “The primary suite feels more like a luxury hotel experience than a traditional bedroom,” the agent noted to Luxury Houses. “It was designed for privacy, comfort, and daily enjoyment of the setting.”
The walk-out lower level transforms the home into a destination for leisure and entertaining. A paneled family room with a fireplace and coffered ceiling is joined by a billiards room, temperature-controlled wine cellar, exercise studio, and a custom onyx wet bar. A soundproofed home theater with coffered ceilings and leather seating completes the level, making 200# Centre Island Road equally suited for intimate evenings or large-scale gatherings.
SEE MORE: New York Luxury Living: A Warm, Traditional-Inspired Home with Modern Flair Asking $12.95 Million
Resort-Style Grounds on Centre Island
Outdoors, the estate rivals a private resort. A generous bluestone patio, outdoor kitchen, and infinity-edge pool overlook the beachfront, while manicured formal gardens, a yoga platform, and a putting green enhance the sense of seclusion. A separate guest suite with its own kitchenette and living area provides flexible accommodations for extended stays.
Located within one of the most exclusive enclaves in Centre Island Real Estate, the property benefits from proximity to yacht clubs, fine dining, and upscale shopping throughout Oyster Bay. Convenient access to regional rail and ferry connections further strengthens the appeal for buyers seeking a refined waterfront lifestyle within the broader New York Real Estate landscape.
SEE MORE: Live the Fantasy: Old Brookville’s Most Alluring $6.5M Estate Hits the Market
Transaction History and Long-Term Value
Public records indicate the property last sold in 2007 for $2.75 million prior to the construction of the current residence, underscoring the dramatic appreciation of premier waterfront land in this market. Earlier transfers dating back to the early 1990s further highlight the site’s enduring desirability. As the agent summarized to Luxury Houses Magazine, “Homes of this caliber, with this level of frontage and privacy, rarely trade hands. 200# Centre Island Road is the kind of legacy property buyers hold for generations.”
Full property details, photos, and additional market insights are available through the Zillow listing, while the property is represented by Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty.
* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*
More Homes in New York here:
- Classic Grandeur Meets the Water: A $8.5M Manor Overlooking Oyster Bay Harbor
- An Iconic $18M North Fork Waterfront Retreat with Exceptional Privacy
- Live the Fantasy: Old Brookville’s Most Alluring $6.5M Estate Hits the Market
- New York Luxury Living: A Warm, Traditional-Inspired Home with Modern Flair Asking $12.95 Million
