Stunning 25 Brewster Lane: Brand-New Waterfront Estate in Prestigious Strong’s Neck, East Setauket, Asking $12.5 Million

Date of Publishing: May 17, 2025

Set on the coveted coastline of Port Jefferson Harbor, 25 Brewster Lane redefines East Setauket real estate with a rare blend of architectural splendor, technological sophistication, and uninterrupted waterfront serenity. This brand-new, 13,029-square-foot estate is the crown jewel of Strong’s Neck—one of Long Island’s most prestigious enclaves—offering not just a home, but a lifestyle.

Crafted in 2024, the residence sits on 3.34 manicured acres, delivering sweeping harbor vistas from nearly every room. “This is not just a house—it’s a vision fully realized,” said listing agent John P. Vitello in an interview with Luxury Houses Magazine. “The owners spared no expense in creating a private retreat where every detail—from radiant heated floors to five custom fireplaces—was chosen with purpose.”

SEE MORE: Classic Coastal Luxury: $9.999M Long Island Sound Estate Built in 1935 with Unrivaled Panoramic Vistas

An Interior of Artistry and Comfort

Inside, the home unfolds across three elevator-connected levels, anchored by a dramatic entryway that leads to a sun-splashed great room overlooking the water. The chef’s kitchen is a masterpiece in itself, featuring a massive island, top-of-the-line appliances, and seamless flow into the breakfast area, formal dining room, and a sleek lounge with bar and fireplace. A home theater and a first-floor guest suite round out the main level, combining practicality with polish.

Upstairs, the primary suite commands the home’s most commanding views, offering floor-to-ceiling windows, a private study, spa-inspired bath, and dual dressing rooms. Four additional ensuite bedrooms provide five-star comfort for family or guests, each designed with custom finishes and generous proportions.

“This home was built for multigenerational luxury,” noted Shan Chowdhury, also of Brown Harris Stevens. “It balances private spaces with open entertaining zones, making it ideal for both intimate evenings and grand celebrations.”

SEE MORE: New York Luxury Redefined: $12.9M Estate on 1.4 Scenic Acres with Panoramic Water Vistas

Resort-Style Amenities, Inside and Out

25 Brewster Lane’s lower level is its own wellness and leisure destination, featuring a full gym, golf simulator, and game room—all finished to the same exacting standards as the upper floors. The indoor pool, complete with a waterfall feature, creates a spa-like atmosphere year-round, while the infinity-edge outdoor pool visually merges with the harbor beyond, evoking the ambiance of a five-star resort.

Beautifully landscaped terraces, a full outdoor kitchen, and multiple walk-out entertaining areas blur the lines between indoor and outdoor living. A protected mooring area allows for direct marine access, with potential for dock installation for those seeking seamless waterfront adventures.

SEE MORE: New York’s Ultimate Waterfront Luxury: A Custom-Built Estate Listed for $24.75 Million

A Storied Location in Long Island’s Crown Jewel

Beyond the gates of 25 Brewster Lane, residents enjoy proximity to Port Jefferson Village—renowned for its upscale boutiques, gourmet dining, and bustling marina life. Top-tier schools and healthcare facilities, along with convenient access to the Port Jefferson Ferry and major highways, make this an address of both luxury and practicality.

“This part of East Setauket real estate is steeped in history and prestige,” said Vitello. “It’s rare to find new construction here, especially of this caliber. This home is not just beautiful—it’s future-proof.”

With a 2019 transaction on the same parcel recorded at $2.5 million, this newly completed estate—now listed at $12,500,000—represents not only a lifestyle investment but also significant appreciation potential in the broader New York real estate landscape.

25 Brewster Lane is more than just one of the most exquisite Luxury Long Island Homes to hit the market—it’s a landmark of modern craftsmanship in a setting rich with historical character. It is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to acquire newly constructed waterfront property in a community where such offerings are virtually nonexistent.