Exceptional $6.9 Million Waterfront Estate Offering Rare Privacy in Prestigious Marco Island
A new listing has quietly entered the luxury market on Marco Island, and it is already drawing attention among discerning buyers seeking privacy, scale, and long-term value. Priced at $6.9 million, 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr offers a rare combination of waterfront living and near-total seclusion within the historic, guard-gated community of Key Marco, one of the most discreet residential enclaves in Marco Island real estate.
Set on nearly an acre of land with highly sought-after southern exposure, the estate overlooks Barfield Bay and a protected natural preserve, allowing for uninterrupted views of colorful sunrises, glowing sunsets, and the distant Marco Island skyline. Properties with this level of privacy and environmental buffer have become increasingly scarce, positioning 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr as a compelling opportunity for buyers searching for a truly private home in Marco Island for sale.
A Landmark Waterfront Home in Marco Island
Built in 2004, 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr was designed with elevation, resilience, and architectural longevity in mind. The contemporary residence spans 6,836 square feet of air-conditioned living space across three levels, all connected by a private elevator that enhances both comfort and accessibility. From the outset, the home was envisioned as a retreat, one that embraces its surroundings rather than competing with them.
Floor-to-ceiling windows, impact-rated doors, and expansive terraces ensure that nearly every room captures views of the bay or preserve. The architectural layout prioritizes openness while maintaining defined living zones, allowing the home to function equally well as a full-time residence or a refined seasonal escape within the broader Marco Island home for sale market.
“This is a property where privacy is not an afterthought, it’s the defining characteristic,” said James Prange of Premier Sotheby’s International Realty in an interview with Luxury Houses Magazine. “You’re surrounded by nature on all sides, yet you remain only minutes from everything Marco Island has to offer.”
SEE MORE: $17.9 Million Turnkey Waterfront Estate Offers Exceptional Living in Port Royal, Naples
An Interior Experience Defined by Space, Light, and Comfort
Inside, the home balances elegance with a relaxed coastal sensibility. Five en-suite bedrooms are distributed across the residence, complemented by six full bathrooms and two additional half baths. Volume ceilings, tray details, French doors, and a combination of stone and tile flooring reinforce the home’s sense of scale without sacrificing warmth.
Formal and informal living and dining areas are arranged to maximize flexibility, making the property equally suited for intimate family living or large-scale entertaining. A gas fireplace anchors one of the primary living spaces, while custom closets, a wet bar, and built-in features add layers of refinement throughout the interior.
Luxury Houses Magazine reached out to the current owners to gain insight into their vision for the property, but they declined to comment publicly. According to Prange, however, the residence has been meticulously maintained and thoughtfully upgraded over time. “The owners treated this as a long-term sanctuary,” he noted. “Every update was made with quality and livability in mind.”
SEE MORE: $16.7 Million Newly Built Estate Sets a New Benchmark for Luxury Living in Pinecrest
Resort-Style Outdoor Living Overlooking Barfield Bay
One of the most significant enhancements to 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr in recent years has been the creation of a state-of-the-art heated saltwater swimming pool and oversized spa. Designed to echo the tranquility of the surrounding preserve, the outdoor environment includes expansive decking, retaining walls, and a fully equipped outdoor kitchen with both open-air and covered spaces.
The result is an outdoor setting that functions as an extension of the home’s interior rather than a separate amenity. Whether swimming laps in the morning, reading beneath covered terraces, or entertaining guests as the sun sets over the bay, the experience is immersive and serene.
“The outdoor living here rivals that of a private resort,” Prange told Luxury Houses. “It’s elegant but casual, and it perfectly reflects the Southwest Florida lifestyle.”
Multiple terraces across all three levels further elevate the experience, offering shifting perspectives of the water, mangroves, and sky throughout the day. From watching summer storms roll in to gazing at stars at night, the setting reinforces the sense that 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr is a place designed for reflection and retreat.
A Transaction History That Mirrors Marco Island’s Evolution
Public records and multiple listing data reviewed by Luxury Houses Magazine confirm that the financial journey of 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr closely parallels the broader evolution of luxury values across Marco Island real estate. The property sold for $1.1 million in 2010, before changing hands again in 2016 for $1.3 million and in 2021 for $1.9 million.
“Homes of this size and setting in Key Marco are increasingly being viewed as legacy assets rather than traditional vacation homes,” Prange added. “There simply aren’t many opportunities left like this.”
Its current $6.85 million listing reflects not only extensive upgrades but also the growing demand for private, waterfront estates within gated communities like Key Marco. Limited inventory and heightened interest from high-net-worth buyers have steadily reshaped pricing dynamics, particularly for homes offering privacy and direct water access.
SEE MORE: $33.3 Million Ultra-Luxury Waterfront Estate Sets a Bold New Standard in Jupiter Real Estate
Life in Key Marco: Privacy Without Compromise
Key Marco, also known as Horr’s Island, is revered for its sense of quiet exclusivity in Florida. The guard-gated community offers residents assigned boat slips with Gulf access, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness and community center, fishing piers, and scenic walking and biking paths that wind through preserved landscapes.
Despite its secluded atmosphere, 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr remains remarkably well connected. Marco Island’s beaches, restaurants, fitness studios, grocery stores, and essential services are located within approximately six miles, while Naples’ renowned dining, shopping, and cultural offerings are easily accessible. Southwest Florida International Airport provides convenient regional and national travel options, further enhancing the home’s appeal as both a primary residence and a lock-and-leave retreat.
This balance between privacy and accessibility continues to attract buyers seeking a home in Marco Island for sale that supports both everyday living and long-term investment goals.
A Secure, Turnkey Estate for the Modern Luxury Buyer
Additional features reinforce the home’s turnkey appeal, including an air-conditioned three-car garage renovated in 2024 with epoxy flooring, commercial-grade shelving, and a Tesla EV charger. Impact windows and doors, a tile roof, and elevated construction contribute to a heightened sense of security and durability, qualities increasingly prioritized by buyers in coastal markets.
With its architectural scale, tranquil setting, and thoughtful upgrades, 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr stands out as one of the most compelling offerings currently available in the Marco Island home for sale landscape.
As inventory continues to tighten and demand for private waterfront estates grows, properties of this caliber, particularly within communities as discreet as Key Marco, remain exceptionally rare. For buyers seeking a lifestyle-driven acquisition rooted in privacy, comfort, and enduring value, 1144 Blue Hill Creek Dr represents a distinctive opportunity within Marco Island real estate. To know more information about this property, view on Zillow listing.
For inquiries or to schedule a private showing, please contact:
James Prange
239-595-0701
Premier Sotheby’s International Realty
* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*
More Homes in Florida here:
- Exceptional $6.9 Million Waterfront Estate Offering Rare Privacy in Prestigious Marco Island
- $17.9 Million Turnkey Waterfront Estate Offers Exceptional Living in Port Royal, Naples
- $16.7 Million Newly Built Estate Sets a New Benchmark for Luxury Living in Pinecrest
- $33.3 Million Ultra-Luxury Waterfront Estate Sets a Bold New Standard in Jupiter Real Estate
