8501 Midnight Pass Rd: $31.5 Million Bayfront Estate Redefines Sarasota Luxury Living

Date of Publishing: April 3, 2025

Architectural Excellence at 8501 Midnight Pass Rd

Set on nearly 3 acres of pristine bayfront on Siesta Key, the newly constructed residence at 8501 Midnight Pass Rd is more than just a home – it’s a modern coastal sanctuary. Listed at $31.5 million, this West Indies-style masterpiece offers 11,606 square feet of refined living space, brought to life by Stofft Cooney Architects and Florida West Builders.

Luxury waterfront estate at 8501 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota with private dock and bay views

“This estate was designed with a focus on blending tropical elegance with state-of-the-art comfort,” said Roger Pettingell of Coldwell Banker Realty in an interview with Luxury Houses Magazine. “Every room captures the water, light, and luxury in equal measure.”

Completed in 2024, the estate features six en-suite bedrooms, ten bathrooms, and uninterrupted views over 217 feet of Sarasota Bay frontage. The home’s architectural elegance, elevated positioning, and seamless indoor-outdoor design establish it as one of the finest home in Sarasota for sale.

Meticulous Craftsmanship Meets Modern Coastal Living

Entering through a gated Tabby seashell driveway, guests are greeted by a dramatic porte-cochère flanked by breezeways and tropical landscaping. The main residence includes a three-car garage, while the detached guest house offers a four-car garage and private quarters with a full kitchen and pecky cypress-paneled living room.

Inside, floor-to-ceiling impact glass floods the interiors with natural light and bay views. European oak hardwood floors in Milano finish run throughout the home, complemented by bespoke cabinetry from Campbell Cabinetry Designs and a Control4 smart system managing lighting, audio, and security.

The gourmet kitchen, a focal point of the home, features two oversized islands, Crystallo quartzite counters, a La Cornue range, Francois hood, and two pantries. The spa-like primary suite includes double French doors to the terrace, massive his-and-hers closets, and a bath encircled by a barrel-vaulted ceiling and mosaic flooring.

“What sets this home apart is the intelligent luxury – systems that work seamlessly, spaces that flow naturally,” added Thomas Arbuckle, also of Coldwell Banker. “It’s a residence built to elevate every moment of daily life.”

SEE MORE: European Elegance Meets South Florida Luxury in This $8.6 Million Coral Gables Home

Sarasota Home for Sale Offering Resort-Level Amenities

This exceptional Sarasota home for sale is designed for both elegant entertaining and quiet retreat. Outdoor amenities include a vanishing-edge heated pool with steppingstones, a separate in-ground spa overlooking the bay, and an expansive summer kitchen complete with an island, wraparound bar, and fireplace. The private dock features a 20,000 lb. lift and a floating kayak launch, ideal for boating enthusiasts. To the east of the property, a custom-fenced tennis court and a pavilion equipped with a fireplace and hurricane shutters complete the estate’s resort-like experience.

With total structure area exceeding 17,000 square feet and every detail considered – from safe rooms to smart security and in-law floorplans – this estate defines Sarasota Real Estate at its pinnacle.

“The owners spared no expense in curating every detail,” Pettingell told Luxury Houses. “They envisioned this as a retreat for multi-generational gatherings, and it delivers exactly that.”

SEE MORE: Modern $12.9 Million Waterfront Masterpiece Offers Smart Living and Serene Luxury in Fort Lauderdale

Location, Legacy, and Lasting Value

This home’s location on Siesta Key ensures close proximity to Sarasota’s best beaches, upscale dining, boutique shopping, and the cultural scene of downtown. Renowned spots such as The Summer House, Siesta Key Oyster Bar, and Morton’s Gourmet Market are just minutes away. Residents also enjoy convenient access to Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport and top-rated medical facilities.

This Sarasota real estate has a rich transactional history, having been listed multiple times in the past decade. It was most recently sold in December 2019 for $3,125,000 before undergoing a full-scale reconstruction culminating in this 2024 architectural gem. Now listed at $31,500,000, it represents a dramatic leap in value – and vision.

However, as Roger Pettingell noted, “This home speaks for itself. The design, the site, the craftsmanship – it’s a legacy property in every sense.”

SEE MORE: A $45 Million Lakefront Sanctuary Blending Italian Elegance and South Florida Glamour in Delray Beach

Elevated Living on Siesta Key

What truly distinguishes this residence within the realm of Sarasota Real Estate is its blend of exclusivity and access. While tucked away on a private 2.78-acre waterfront parcel, the estate remains minutes from vibrant coastal culture. Whether enjoying a morning walk along Siesta Beach or an evening at one of downtown Sarasota’s art galleries, the location embodies effortless luxury.

As one of the most prominent homes Florida for sale, 8501 Midnight Pass Rd offers the rare combination of high-end craftsmanship, expansive living, and a setting that balances serenity with sophistication. This is not merely a residence – it is a lifestyle investment that will hold its value for generations.

For more details, visit Zillow listing page or connect with Roger Pettingell at Coldwell Banker Realty.

For inquiries or to schedule a private showing, please contact:

Roger Pettingell
941-387-1840
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Thomas Arbuckle
941-356-0638
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*