4005 Casey Key Rd Lists for $11.9M as a Stunning New Gulffront Estate in Nokomis, Florida

Date of Publishing: April 27, 2025

A Rare Gulffront Opportunity on Casey Key

Set on the powdery shores of Florida’s Gulf Coast, 4005 Casey Key Rd represents a bold architectural statement in a stretch where new beachfront construction is exceedingly rare. Listed at $11.9 million, this 2025-built Modern Coastal estate delivers nearly 8,000 square feet of FEMA-compliant living space, combining safety, sophistication, and oceanfront luxury in equal measure.

Exterior view of 4005 Casey Key Rd, a $11.9 million modern Gulf-front estate in Nokomis, Florida, featuring a rooftop terrace, oceanfront pool, and lush tropical landscaping

The home stands on a 0.47-acre parcel directly fronting the Gulf of Mexico, with the added perk of deeded bay access across the road. Built by Modesta Homes, the residence uses concrete block construction, hurricane-impact-rated glass, pilings, and a full-service four-stop elevator to meet the most demanding structural and lifestyle standards.

“New construction on the sand is virtually non-existent in Nokomis,” Courtney Tarantino of Coldwell Banker Realty told Luxury Houses Magazine. “This Nokomis real estate is the kind of modern Gulffront home buyers from Miami or Malibu dream of, but in a more serene and private setting.”

SEE MORE: A Radiant $11.5 Million Waterfront Estate Redefines Luxury Living in Sunny Isles Beach

Statement Architecture and Bespoke Interiors

Inside, the home in Nokomis for sale welcomes visitors into a 24-foot high foyer where light pours in from floor-to-ceiling windows. A floating staircase and a grand 24-foot fireplace wall set the tone for what is truly a showpiece.

“The attention to materiality is exquisite-imported tile, wide-plank wood flooring, smooth stucco walls, and integrated LED ceilings,” said Jennifer Zales, lead agent for the listing. “This is the kind of detailing we usually see in oceanfront properties two or three times this price.”

The chef’s kitchen anchors the first level with custom European cabinetry, dual quartz waterfall islands, and integrated Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances. A wine wall, sleek bar, and sunlit breakfast nook complete the open-concept entertainment space. The living room, measuring 624 square feet, is designed with indoor-outdoor flow in mind, connecting directly to the pool deck and terrace.

There are six en-suite bedrooms, each designed with built-in closets and spa-quality bathrooms. The primary suite is a sanctuary in itself, complete with dual rainfall showers, a soaking tub, a 400 sq ft walk-in closet, and a makeup vanity surrounded by quartz and backlit mirrors.

SEE MORE: An Exquisite $15.9 Million Tropical Modern Retreat Elevates Luxury Living at 5400 Hammock Dr in Elite Coral Gables

Rooftop, Poolside, and Sunset Living

Outdoor living at 4005 Casey Key Rd mirrors that of a private resort. The rooftop terrace is engineered for panoramic views of the Gulf and is ideal for yoga at sunrise or cocktails at dusk. Below, the oceanfront pool and floating spa are flanked by multiple sun decks, a full summer kitchen, and a gas fireplace-designed to extend alfresco living well into the evening.

“This Nokomis home for sale isn’t just designed to be lived in-it’s meant to be experienced,” noted Courtney Tarantino. “And the rooftop is absolutely my favorite part. There’s nothing like sipping champagne above the Gulf at sunset.”

Zoysia grass, lush tropical foliage, and turf-inlaid concrete driveways give the estate both curb appeal and functional beauty. Metal railings, clean lines, and coastal finishes add modern contrast against the soft natural landscape.

An Impressive Market Journey

The property’s current state marks a dramatic transformation. Once sold in May 2021 for $2,450,000, the lot was previously home to a traditional residence listed multiple times between 2019–2021 in the $2.5M–$3.6M range.

“This isn’t just another flip or cosmetic renovation,” Jennifer Zales told Luxury Houses Magazine. “This is a clean-slate, new construction that raises the bar for Nokomis Real Estate.”

The owners made a bold move by commissioning a total rebuild-culminating in the 2025 completion of this state-of-the-art estate. The shift in value isn’t just a matter of location-it reflects a bold investment in modern architecture and premium coastal living.

SEE MORE: Experience Oceanfront Innovation With This $15.4 Million Tesla-Powered Smart Estate in Fort Lauderdale

The Best of Nokomis and Sarasota County

Located in Sarasota County, Nokomis is an upscale yet understated beach town that offers a quiet alternative to its more tourist-heavy neighbors. Just minutes from Venice, Osprey, and downtown Sarasota, the area boasts art galleries, marinas, five-star restaurants, and award-winning schools.

Airports like Sarasota-Bradenton International (SRQ) and Tampa International (TPA) provide seamless travel access, while cultural venues such as the Van Wezel Performing Arts Hall enrich the local lifestyle.

“Buyers are realizing they can have all the Gulf-front beauty without the crowds,” Jennifer added. “That’s what makes Nokomis home for sale listings like this so rare and valuable.”

Whether you’re searching for a forever residence or a seasonal escape, 4005 Casey Key Rd offers the perfect blend of privacy, panoramic views, and architectural sophistication. As one of the few brand-new listings in Florida, this Nokomis home for sale stands out not just for its Gulf-front setting, but for the elevated lifestyle it delivers. For buyers seeking a turnkey experience with timeless design and access to everything Nokomis real estate has to offer, this is a rare and remarkable opportunity that’s not to be missed.

To schedule a tour or learn more, view Full Listing on Zillow.

For inquiries or to schedule a private showing, please contact:

Jennifer Zales
813-758-3443
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

Courtney Tarantino
941-893-7203
COLDWELL BANKER REALTY

* This property might not for sale at the moment you read this post; please check property status at the above Zillow or Agent website links*