1216 N Casey Key Rd – Stunning $11.75M Waterfront Oasis in Osprey with Breathtaking Gulf-to-Bay Views

Date of Publishing: March 11, 2025

A Rare Opportunity to Own a Premier Osprey Home for Sale

Located on the exclusive northern tip of Casey Key, one of Sarasota County’s most coveted addresses, 1216 N Casey Key Rd presents an extraordinary opportunity to own a timeless waterfront estate. With 5 bedrooms, 8 bathrooms, and over 8,050 sq. ft. of luxurious living space, this Mediterranean-style home seamlessly blends classic architecture with modern amenities, offering a truly unparalleled coastal lifestyle in this home in Osprey for sale.

Grand Living Room with Cypress-Beamed Ceilings – Elegant living space with custom woodwork, French doors, and breathtaking water views in this luxury Osprey home for sale

The 1.10-acre lot ensures privacy while providing stunning Gulf-to-Bay views, making this a rare find in the high-end Osprey Home for Sale market. With access to both private beachfront and a covered boat dock, this property is ideal for those who appreciate the balance between serene waterfront living and adventurous marine activities.

Timeless Design Meets Modern Elegance

Designed by renowned architect Clifford A. Scholz and built by Delta Southern Construction, this estate was thoughtfully crafted in 1999 to maximize its breathtaking views and provide the ultimate in luxury living. The residence extends from the Gulf of Mexico’s sandy shores to a rare covered boat dock on Blackburn Bay, making it a haven for those who appreciate both beachside serenity and boating convenience.

“This estate was meticulously designed to offer a seamless blend of traditional craftsmanship and contemporary luxury. Every detail, from the custom woodwork to the breathtaking water views, speaks to the unparalleled quality of this property,” said Valerie Dall’Acqua, the listing agent from Premier Sotheby’s International Realty.

Inside, the estate features cypress-beamed ceilings, leaded glass doors, and French doors opening onto stone terraces that lead to an infinity-edge pool overlooking the water. The grand living room, accented by rich wooden details, is designed for both intimate gatherings and grand entertaining. An elegant marble staircase leads to the upper level, offering panoramic views of the coastline.

SEE MORE: Lavish Palm Beach Oceanfront Mansion with Resort-Style Pool and Panoramic Views Lists for $45 Million

Luxurious Interior & Thoughtful Layout

The primary suite is a sanctuary, complete with a sitting area, lavish bath, dual walk-in closets, and a private breakfast nook with stunning water views. The spa-like bathroom features a deep soaking tub, dual vanities, and custom stonework, adding to the ambiance of luxury. Three additional en-suite guest bedrooms offer privacy and comfort, while the fifth suite is currently designed as a home gym with a steam room and sauna.

For those who enjoy hosting, the gourmet kitchen features granite countertops, a butler’s pantry, a wine refrigerator, and a wet bar, making entertaining effortless. The state-of-the-art appliances, including Sub-Zero refrigerators and Wolf ovens, ensure a culinary experience of the highest quality. Additional living spaces include a formal dining room, a grand media room, and an office/library with custom-built shelving and a coffered ceiling, offering refined sophistication.

SEE MORE: Experience Ultimate Waterfront Living in Eastern Shores, A $7.3 Millon Luxury Haven

Unparalleled Outdoor Living

A home of this caliber would not be complete without an exceptional outdoor living space. French doors open to multiple stone terraces leading to a resort-style infinity pool. A fully equipped outdoor kitchen, fire pit, and multiple lounge areas make the backyard an entertainer’s dream.

“The outdoor living spaces are just as impressive as the interiors. From the infinity pool to the private boat dock, this home offers an unrivaled waterfront experience that is truly one-of-a-kind in Osprey Real Estate,” shared a representative from Premier Sotheby’s International Realty.

The deep-water dock, featuring a grandfathered-in covered boat lift, provides direct access to the Intracoastal Waterway and the Gulf of Mexico, making it an ideal property for yachting enthusiasts. With its expansive waterfront views, private beach access, and tranquil surroundings, this estate is one of the finest examples of luxury in Osprey Real Estate.

An elevator and a six-car garage add to the estate’s convenience and exclusivity, ensuring easy access across all levels of the home.

SEE MORE: Inside a $15.5 Million Marco Island Estate with Gulf Views and Private Deepwater Dock

The Prestigious Casey Key Lifestyle

Located within Casey Key, an exclusive enclave known for its privacy, pristine beaches, and elite real estate, this estate offers seclusion without sacrificing access to world-class amenities. Residents enjoy a laid-back, yet sophisticated, coastal lifestyle, with easy access to boutique shopping, gourmet dining, and championship golf courses in Sarasota and Venice.

According to Valerie Dall’Acqua of Premier Sotheby’s International Realty, the listing agent for this estate, “1216 N Casey Key Rd is a true masterpiece that encapsulates waterfront luxury. It’s rare to find a property that offers both Gulf-front and bay-front access in such an exclusive setting.“

For those seeking an active lifestyle, boating, paddleboarding, and fishing are just steps from your backyard, while nearby nature trails and parks provide additional outdoor recreation.

A Look at the Estate’s Sales History

Originally purchased for $1,150,000 in 1995, the estate has since undergone meticulous enhancements, maintaining its stature as one of Casey Key’s finest properties. It is now listed for $11,750,000, reflecting its unparalleled features and prime waterfront location in Osprey Real Estate.

This stunning Osprey Home for Sale stands out in Sarasota County’s luxury market, offering a timeless investment opportunity. Luxury Houses Magazine reached out to the current owner for insights into the estate’s unique features but has not yet received a response.

An Exclusive Opportunity

For discerning buyers looking for a waterfront masterpiece in Osprey, 1216 N Casey Key Rd offers an unmatched blend of privacy, luxury, and coastal elegance. With its prime location, exquisite design, and unmatched amenities, this property is a true representation of high-end Osprey Real Estate. This estate is not just a home – it’s an experience, a retreat, and a statement of refined living.