There Are Just Four Homes on This Private Muirfield Village Lake. One Is for Sale for $6.895 Million.

The nearly 10,000-square-foot Ohio estate in Dublin, tucked behind a second gate in Nicklaus Estates, has been extensively reworked with a separate guest house, 10 fireplaces, an infinity pool and an acoustically engineered theater.

At Muirfield Village, golf is the obvious attraction. But the defining feature of 5340 Muirfield Court is something considerably scarcer: its position on the water.

The Dublin, Ohio, property is one of just four homes positioned around a private lake within Nicklaus Estates, a gated enclave inside Muirfield Village Golf Club, according to the listing. Now asking $6.895 million, the six-bedroom residence encompasses 9,858 square feet on just under an acre and includes a separate guest house.

Built in 1998, the estate has undergone an extensive renovation rather than simply receiving a cosmetic update. The listing says every surface has been refinished, replaced or restored, with new mechanical systems, windows, doors, flooring, appliances and lighting among the changes.

That work gives the house an unusual proposition: the scale and established setting of a late-1990s estate, but interiors intended to feel essentially unused.

Listing agents Ashley Oliver of Keller Williams Greater Columbus and Sarah Claypool of Rock House Realty describe it as a “true top-to-bottom transformation,” saying the renovation has created a “pristine, never-lived-in feel.”

Yet the renovation isn’t the part of the property that would be hardest to reproduce.

That distinction belongs to the lake.

A Second Gate Leads to One of the Enclave’s Rarest Lots

Privacy at 5340 Muirfield Court begins before reaching the front door.

The house sits behind the second gate of Nicklaus Estates within Muirfield Village Golf Club, adding another layer of separation within an already exclusive residential setting.

Its position around the private lake narrows the field further. According to the listing, only four residences share this distinction.

For a buyer considering an estate in an established golf community, that scarcity matters. Kitchens can be replaced and swimming pools refinished, but a residence cannot be renovated onto a lakefront parcel that it does not already occupy.

The roughly 0.95-acre lot also provides a relatively intimate setting for a house approaching 10,000 square feet. Rather than relying on vast acreage to create separation, the property uses gates, mature greenery and its relationship with the lake to establish privacy.

It is a different type of estate from one defined primarily by land.

Here, the value of the site lies in precisely where that land happens to be.

Ten Fireplaces Run Through Three Levels

Inside, the house unfolds over three levels, with spaces intended to accommodate both daily living and much larger gatherings.

One number immediately stands out: 10 fireplaces.

Distributed through the residence, they bring a more traditional architectural rhythm to rooms that have otherwise been substantially modernized. That contrast is important because the renovation does not appear to have been conceived as an attempt to erase the house’s original character.

Instead, the property combines established architecture with new finishes and systems.

Refinished or replaced flooring runs throughout, accompanied by new doors and windows. Restoration Hardware lighting has been installed across the interiors, while the great-room fixture sits on a lift that allows it to be accessed from the upper level for maintenance.

It is a small engineering detail, but one that illustrates the practical challenges that come with rooms of this scale. A dramatic chandelier is one thing; being able to reach it without scaffolding is another.

The Renovation Goes Beyond What You Can See

Some of the most consequential improvements at 5340 Muirfield Court are not decorative.

New mechanical systems accompany the renovation, while an integrated smart-home platform uses touchscreen controls to manage the residence. Whole-home audio has also been installed.

The kitchen has been updated with new appliances, and the house contains two laundry rooms equipped with a combined four sets of washers and dryers.

That might sound excessive in a conventional residence. In a nearly 10,000-square-foot estate with six bedrooms and separate guest accommodations, it begins to look more like infrastructure.

The renovation’s breadth is central to the property’s current positioning. Oliver and Claypool say “every surface has been refinished, replaced, or meticulously restored,” an unusually comprehensive claim that suggests the project was intended to address the house as a whole rather than modernize only its most visible rooms.

For buyers comparing a renovated estate with new construction, that distinction can be significant.

A new kitchen photographs well. New windows, mechanicals and systems affect how a house actually operates.

Downstairs, the Theater Was Engineered for Sound

The lower level contains one of the renovation’s more technically focused spaces.

A dedicated theater has been completely remodeled and acoustically engineered, according to the listing. It incorporates a JBL Synthesis surround-sound system and a 100-inch LED screen.

Acoustic engineering separates the room from the increasingly common practice of placing a large television and theater seating in a finished basement and calling the result a cinema.

Here, sound itself was part of the design brief.

That attention to performance fits with the broader renovation. Technology is present throughout the property, but much of it has been integrated into the architecture rather than treated as a collection of standalone gadgets.

The smart-home controls, whole-house audio and theater system are all examples of technology intended to disappear into the experience of using the house.

The Guest House Gives Visitors Their Own Address Within the Estate

The six-bedroom count includes another feature that expands how the property can function: a separate guest house.

It, too, has been completely remodeled.

For an estate designed for entertaining, physical separation can be more valuable than simply adding another guest suite to the main residence. Visitors can remain within the property while retaining a degree of independence from the household.

The arrangement could also make the estate more adaptable for extended family or longer stays, without requiring the principal house to absorb every residential function.

Outside, the refinished infinity pool provides another gathering point.

Surrounded by greenery, the pool has been positioned as a private retreat rather than a highly exposed centerpiece. Together with the lake setting, it gives the property two distinct relationships with water: one recreational and contained, the other natural to the home’s position within the enclave.

A four-car heated garage completes the principal amenity package.

Readers can explore the renovated interiors, private lake setting, guest house and infinity pool through the complete Zillow presentation here.

Muirfield Village Is More Than the Backdrop

The address carries significance beyond the boundaries of the property.

Muirfield Village is closely associated with golf, and the estate’s location within Nicklaus Estates places it inside a residential environment shaped by that identity.

But 5340 Muirfield Court does not depend on golf-course frontage as its principal differentiator.

Instead, its private-lake position gives it another layer of scarcity within the community. For a buyer who wants the Muirfield Village setting but values privacy and water views, that distinction may be more important than direct exposure to the course.

The second gate reinforces the sense of enclosure, while the separate guest house, mature landscaping and infinity pool allow much of the property’s lifestyle to remain self-contained.

The result is a house connected to one of the area’s best-known residential settings without making the surrounding community its entire story.

The Asking Price Is 84% Above Its 2021 Sale

The current $6.895 million asking price represents a substantial step up from the property’s last recorded transaction.

According to the supplied price history, the estate sold for $3.75 million in July 2021. It returned to the market on Aug. 13, 2026, at $6.895 million, or approximately $699 per square foot.

That is roughly $3.145 million more than the 2021 sale price, an increase of about 84%.

Unlike situations where an earlier transaction involved vacant land or preceded construction of the current residence, both figures here relate to a house originally built in 1998. But treating the difference as simple market appreciation would still be misleading.

The current listing describes an extensive intervening transformation encompassing virtually the entire property, including mechanical systems, windows, doors, flooring, lighting, appliances, technology, the theater, guest house and infinity pool.

Without verified renovation costs, it isn’t possible to separate the contribution of those improvements from changes in the underlying market or the seller’s current pricing expectations.

And $6.895 million remains an asking price, not a completed sale.

What the history does show is that the property being marketed today is being positioned very differently from the one that changed hands five years ago.

The Renovation Can Be Repeated. The Address Can’t.

There are two competing stories at 5340 Muirfield Court.

The first is about transformation.

A 1998 residence has been comprehensively reworked, with contemporary systems and finishes introduced throughout nearly 10,000 square feet. The guest house has been remodeled. The infinity pool has been refinished. The theater has been acoustically engineered. Even the practical infrastructure—from mechanicals to laundry capacity—has received attention.

The second story is much simpler.

There are four houses around this particular private lake.

That is ultimately what gives the property a different kind of permanence. Another owner could renovate the interiors again 15 years from now. Technology will inevitably evolve, appliances will change and today’s finishes will eventually become another era’s renovation project.

The home’s position within Nicklaus Estates will remain considerably harder to alter.

At $6.895 million, the sellers are offering both sides of the equation: a house that has already undergone the disruptive work of a major renovation, and a site whose scarcity existed long before the renovation began.

Property Overview

5340 Muirfield Court in Dublin, Ohio, is offered at $6.895 million. Built in 1998, the residence encompasses approximately 9,858 square feet on a 0.95-acre lot and contains six bedrooms and 6.5 bathrooms, represented in the supplied property summary as seven total baths.

The three-level house has undergone an extensive renovation encompassing finishes, flooring, doors, windows, mechanical systems, lighting and appliances. It features 10 fireplaces, an integrated smart-home system, whole-home audio and two laundry rooms with four sets of washers and dryers.

The lower level includes an acoustically engineered theater with JBL Synthesis surround sound and a 100-inch LED screen. The property also has a remodeled separate guest house, four-car heated garage and refinished infinity pool.

The estate is located behind the second gate of Nicklaus Estates within Muirfield Village Golf Club and, according to the listing, is one of only four residences positioned around its private lake.

Listing Representation

Ashley Oliver of Keller Williams Greater Columbus and Sarah Claypool of Rock House Realty represent 5340 Muirfield Court.

The agents describe the property as a “top-to-bottom transformation,” emphasizing that its surfaces have been refinished, replaced or restored to create what they characterize as a “pristine, never-lived-in feel.”

For additional information or private-showing inquiries:

Ashley Oliver
Keller Williams Greater Columbus
Phone: 614-956-9886

Sarah Claypool
Rock House Realty LLC
Phone: 614-747-2155